It is impossible to imagine Randall Scarlata singing a mechanical or thoughtless phrase. One has the wonderful sense that Scarlata searches out the Platonic essence of anything he plans to sing and then uses every attribute at his disposal to create the most appropriate and fully dimensional realization possible."
Die Schöne Müllerin
"An imposing rather than a flashy performer, Scarlata shaped his sound -- with a manifold array of timbres -- to emphasize single words and the moods (from exhilarating to morbid) of each setting. Denk's phrasing, coloring and tempos reinforced Scarlata's dramatic force."